Keeping it Real



This past holiday season, while scanning for the top and recent movie titles on Netflix, the word “catfishing” caught my attention. I learned that catfishing means the deceptive act of creating fake online identities to lure folks into false relationships. The movie, “Love Hard”, where I encountered the word, was about online dating, which started with the protagonist finding herself the perfect match online after several failed attempts at dating before. Not only is this guy good looking, she is having interesting conversations with him, sharing many common interests and just feels such a strong connection with him that it feels too good to be true ! She travels across the country to surprise him. Instead, she is in for a rude shock when she finds out he looks nothing like his profile picture. The plot takes a few sweet turns when the guy promises to introduce her to the real person in the picture. She tries to date the other guy, but realizes that she had developed a connection with the first guy even if he didn’t look like the picture. Though the picture was fake, the guy she connected to was real.

While the movie starts by highlighting catfishing, it ends with the more profound message that appearance isn’t everything. I thought the message is very relevant in the current landscape where the most popular social media platforms are encouraging people to consume pictures and create an environment of unhealthy competition of producing the “perfect” pictures. This is putting an unwarranted pressure, mostly on young minds, who are trying to establish an identity for themselves. The visual nature of today’s popular social networking platforms such as instagram, snapchat, tiktok put a high premium on appearance. And it is very easy for young minds to get sucked into a virtual world that could well be smoke and mirrors. With polished, curated and filtered images and videos, young people feel they have to look a certain way based on the posted images on these platforms.

Covid and lockdowns taught us that there is definitely value in social networks and the virtual world. However while accepting the value it is important to separate the fake from the real. While hiding behind the anonymity of a virtual identity, it can be tempting to put up a fake front - which is the basis of the virtual world being rooted in fake - fake profiles, fake stories, fake news, fake pictures.


Researchers, psychologists and even regular people with common sense could see that these platforms and the way they are used, couldn’t be healthy - especially for the younger generation in their formative years. I remember a wise gentleman calling it “Fakebook” and refusing to have anything to do with it. Tristan Harris (@tristanharris) ex-google felt so strongly about the social networking giants focusing on increasing user attention, retention and their bottomline without owning up to social responsibility, that he left google to start his non-profit in 2015 to spread the message. The Netflix documentary “The Social Dilemma” (2020), raises awareness how the “technology that connects us also manipulates, distracts, divides, controls, polarizes and monetizes”.

It took a whistleblower from Facebook and an article reported by the Wall Street Journal for people to take more seriously what researchers had been saying for a while. Among other alarming findings it came to light that Facebook knew but did nothing with its internal research that instagram was toxic for teen girls’ mental health - making girls feel worse about themselves, causing eating disorders, increasing depression and suicidality. Tech giants have justified with the standard argument that these are tools and like any tool the onus of using it responsibly is on its users. However, like other harmful products such as guns, drugs, or toxic toys, lawmakers are on a path to put the responsibility on the product makers via the The Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) (One pager).

The fact remains that these are useful connectivity tools that are here to stay. And the answer isn’t “they are harmful, don’t use them!”. For the time being, there may be some simple ways to combat triggering posts. One can use certain apps settings to disable algorithmic feeds (search on “how to change the settings to show less of what triggers you” for your social media apps). For example, there is the “Not interested” on Instagram posts, or turning the Limit or Limit even more on the sensitive control setting. On a more philosophical side, one can try to get a reality check on a post that’s causing angst. The realization that the person posting is not meaning personal harm and may themselves be going through some rough times, can be liberating. And if one genuinely feels there is intentional harm like cyberbullying or manipulative spread of fake news, block it if it triggers, or speak up if one feels up to it. Question one's own intent for a post and try to keep it real. Doesn’t mean we need to post our ugliest pictures, but knowing that looking real isn’t such a bad thing. Connecting with and meeting real friends (this was difficult during covid) and planning real activities that one enjoys brings the appreciation of the real world. Asking oneself if one could say the same thing to someone’s face, that one is so quick to post online - can develop a skill in honest, personal communication.

The original intent of online profiles and persona in social media and social networks is to mirror and represent our real personalities in the virtual world. However, human beings’ powerful imagination allows us to spin our stories in the way we want to present them to the world. It gives us the power to curate our profile by purging the parts of us which we may not like about ourselves at that moment rather than accept, love, nurture and develop ourselves into the beautiful beings that we are. It is our choice whether we represent ourselves falsely and unknowingly harm ourselves or we keep it real!

Image credit : Tristan photo from the Ellen Show
















Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Local Impact

Image
“What’s up with the orange ribbon on your mailbox post?” I was glad for the question, as that was precisely the purpose of the tied up piece of ribbon.  The Orange Ribbon Campaign , a student led initiative started by the Luce family of Boxborough, amplified by AB Together Against Hate and AB United Way (ABUW), is a show of support and solidarity towards Black, Indigenous and People of Color communities. Recently two Black members of our town school committee experienced blatant racial attacks with use of slurs - on two separate occasions - during meetings held over zoom. There has been a widespread support for the orange ribbon initiative. “We realize that a ribbon campaign will not change hearts and minds or discriminatory practices, but we hope to amplify the many voices and groups that need to be heard” states the campaign. When a member of our community, Ananya Rao , reached out for 20 volunteers, the spots were full within no time. I was motivated by the fact that the ...
Read more

The Flight of an Empty Nester

Image
I settled down on the couch by the fireplace, wrapping myself with a warm blanket and a mug of hot ginger tea in hand, when my whatsapp notification dinged with a photo of my cousin Seema, receiving a trophy for a marathon run. Before I had a chance to read the details, our dog Smokey started pawing me vigorously - his unwavering, piercing stare reminding me that it was time for his walk. Six o’clock on a dark, cold, winter evening isn’t my favorite time to walk. However, it can be very difficult to explain to a dog, eager for his evening walk, about the lethargy of a cold, winter evening, that us humans experience. With the image of my marathoner cousin in the back of my head, and the love for my demanding doggie, I quickly gulped down the tea, admonishing Smokey to be patient.  Following the advice of a good friend, who was a dog owner before us, “There is no such thing as bad weather, only bad clothes”, I layered myself with warm clothing, ready to face the bitter wind chill o...
Read more

The Undeniable Roots

Image
The grocery store was out of ginger root today. Usually ginger is a grocery item I can safely find in abundance, always filling up its designated area to capacity. On regular days, it seems like I am the only one stuffing my produce bag with four or five large roots. Ginger is an essential ingredient in Indian cooking. And those fond of the real Indian chai (tea) won't have it without a generous helping of ginger; it is known to fight colds and coughs and is supposed to bring warmth. I wasn’t surprised that today, with everyone guarding against COVID-19, the produce aisle which normally carries ginger was full of artichokes. If stores could be out of toilet paper, being out of ginger made way more sense. The sudden popularity of this root, which is such an integral part of my Indian roots, started me thinking of my roots. In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, I sit here, about 7500 miles away, across most of the Atlantic ocean, Europe and the middle-east, concerned abou...
Read more

74th Indian Independence Day

Image
Proud Indian Americans looked on with their heads held high as they witnessed the Indian Flag being raised at the Acton town hall, accompanied by Jana-Gana-Mana, the Indian National Anthem. The Indian Flag will fly for twenty four hours at the Acton Town Center to commemorate India’s 74th Independence Day, on August 15th 2020. This is happening for the first time in the history of Acton, thanks to the leadership of the Acton Board of Selectmen (BOS) and Sahana Purohit, a Finance Committee member, who stepped  up promptly in response to IAGB (India Association of Greater Boston http://www.iagb.org ) initiative to hoist the Indian flag in 35 New England cities including Nashua, Connecticut and Maine towns. In Acton, the occasion was graced by prominent town representatives such as Massachusetts State Senator Jamie Eldridge, Massachusetts Representatives Tami Gouveia and Dan Sena,  Acton Board of Selectmen (BOS) Chair Jon Benson and Vice Chair Dean Charter, Selectman David Mart...
Read more

Youth Junction

Image
Six years ago, after completing his business degree (BBA), a young apprentice started his business journey in the newly inaugurated family garment store called Youth Junction. There was excitement around this new store in the small farming community of Timarni, Madhya Pradesh, India. Now fashion-seeking youngsters did not have to make a four hour hike to nearby cities of Bhopal or Indore for trendy outfits. For the Gadres, especially Siddharth, Youth Junction is a bold endeavor; a family dream come true. Siddharth has been managing the store with his Dad, Upendra, for the past six years. On first meeting, Siddharth comes across as a shy youth, but once you get to know him better, he has much to share with you. Siddharth is an iron-willed lionheart. For the past 25 years, after thousands of physical therapy sessions; after a couple of surgeries and years of medical intervention; after trying out every other alternative medicine like homeopathy and ayurvedic, he says he has developed a ...
Read more

The Festival of Lights

Image
We had been in the US for just a few years when our then six-year-old walked into the house announcing how we must have a turkey dinner that Thanksgiving. Everyone at school was talking about it, and he had just learned some great stories about Thanksgiving. We nodded at the stories without complicating the conversation with the questionable origins of the holiday , as we were ready to give this family holiday tradition a try. After all life is about new experiences and what can be better than when food and the whole family are involved! Having been raised in India, growing up we were exposed to Christmas and Ramadan besides other holidays. On moving to the US we used to put up a Christmas tree with presents, got kids’ pictures with Santa and enjoyed a feast with the family on Christmas day. But we had never celebrated Thanksgiving at home, although we knew about it at work and in the context of Black Friday shopping. Being busy working parents with young children at that time, Indian ...
Read more

Eternal Love

Image
The school year 2016-17 in our town started with a dark fall season ending in a darker winter. The school community was mourning, grieving and learning to cope with the deaths of two current students and two past students who took their own lives. Then on a cold, dark winter evening in January when I entered my daughter’s room, she was in shock and unconsolable. “It’s a fifth grader....he is so young...only ten!” That evening is etched in my mind. If it took so much for our family to come to terms with this incident, I wondered what the boy’s family would have gone through. It has been more than four years since this incident, when quite coincidentally I noticed a page set up by a mother in the memory of her radiant boy. I was drawn to this duo and as I looked deeper caught sight of innumerable posts - some touching, some heartbreaking, but mostly inspiring, and tremendously positive in the face of an unthinkable tragedy. My throat tightened as I read “Sometimes it feels like he is jus...
Read more

Journey to the Faraway Land

Image
In the early part of 2021, my friend Sunanda Sahay shared about a project she was spearheading as a part of and initiated by the Acton Historical Society (AHS) and the current co-president Doug Herrick. Over the past couple of decades, especially in the last decade, Acton has been getting a big influx of an Asian population, and the AHS wanted to record this journey through immigrant stories and experiences. The project focused on the two largest demographics, the Chinese American and the Indian American Actonians. The AHS hosted a session in May 2021 representing the Chinese American community that was led by Dawn Wang. A similar session, led by Sunanda, is planned to represent the Indian American on Sunday, Oct 3rd at 4 pm EST. When Sunanda explained the project to me in Jan 2021, I did a quick search to learn about the journeys of Indian American Actonians. About when and why they moved to Acton and what their experience was as a part of raising a family in Acton. I found next to n...
Read more

Age is just a Number

Image
I wasn’t there to witness this amazing feat. But when I close my eyes, it is clear like it is happening right in front of my eyes! I have seen this happen before, however this time it is more exciting for him. His small frame hunched over the keyboard with keys so worn-out that the letters have disappeared, his glasses that need correction that sometimes he can see better without them when his face is up close to the monitor and keyboard, patiently typing with two fingers as he has no typing skills; but his memories are crystal clear and larger than life, pouring out and filling the empty pages of the document to bring the stories of legendary cricketers, whom he hero-worshipped in his youth, to life. My Dad, (whom I call Baba) at age 82, just finished writing and publishing a book of his dreams. While he wrote about the legends, in my eyes he himself has become a legend! In March 2020, when I wrote about Baba in my post “ The Undeniable Roots ” that “When I read motivational quotes ab...
Read more

The Whole Nine Yards

Image
As a child I found comfort in cuddling a soft, warm, dry and fluffy white mass. No, it wasn’t a puppy! It was my grandmother’s nine yard saree (“nauvari”; nau- nine, var - yard; in Marathi) stitched like a quilt. It was extremely soft, being well-worn cotton and washed hundreds of times, folded four times and stitched into a comfortable quilt of a little over 6 feet in length, hence named “chaughadi” (chau - four, ghadi - fold; in Marathi). In the Indian winters it would trap the body heat and provide just enough warmth, and in summers, the airy, light material was the perfect cover under a ceiling fan. Beyond the practical perfectness, it was my inseparable security blanket. So when I first heard the phrase “the whole nine yards” in the US, however bizarre it may sound now, I assumed it was borrowed from the length of the traditional Indian saree. To me the phrase made complete sense - to go the full length or detail into something, as compared to the more modern, and shorter, abridge...
Read more